How to Read Roofer Reviews Before You Hire
Reviews are the first thing most people check before hiring a roofer — which is exactly why reading them well matters. Here's what to look for, what to discount, and how to cross-check what you find.
What genuine reviews of this trade mention
Real customers write about specifics. In reviews of roofers, the most useful signals are:
- whether photos of the problem and the fix were provided
- how long the repair has lasted
- whether scaffolding and skip costs were included upfront
- response time after storm damage
- whether the guarantee arrived in writing
Patterns that deserve suspicion
No single sign proves a review is fake, but several together should make you careful: a burst of short five-star reviews in a few days, vague praise with no job detail, reviewers with only one review ever, or a perfect score on one platform and complaints on another.
Balanced reviews — mostly positive with a small gripe — are often the most trustworthy, because real jobs rarely go perfectly.
Cross-check across platforms
The strongest protection is comparing sources. Hammerscore company pages for roofers bring ratings from different platforms together into one combined score, show which platform each record came from, and link to the original source so you can judge it yourself.
Where a record only holds a rating and not the review text, we say so rather than inventing content — follow the source link to read the original.
Read how the business responds
Replies to criticism tell you how you'll be treated if something goes wrong. A calm response offering to fix the problem is a good sign; aggressive or dismissive replies are not.
If you spot a review on Hammerscore you believe is inaccurate or about the wrong company, use the report button on that review — reports are reviewed by a person, and reporting doesn't automatically remove content.
Check a company now
Search UK trade companies and read their combined reviews before you hire.
Browse companies